It was my birthday and it was my cake and there was one slice of it left on the plate at about four in the afternoon, and I am going to tell you exactly what happened in me, because I do not think anybody tells children the true version of this.
Mrs. Ames makes the cake. It is the same cake every year, it has the thing in the middle, and I think about it in about March.
There were nine of us and it had gone round twice and there was one slice left, and Sam Hollis, who is my friend and who I would give most things to, looked at it.
He did not ask. That is important. He looked at it and then he looked away, and he did it fast, and the whole thing took about half a second and I saw it happen.
And what happened in me is that I got a grip on that plate. Not with my hand. I did not move at all. Something in my chest closed like a gate closing and I had a complete argument ready inside about four seconds, and the argument was: it is my birthday and it is my cake and I have had two slices and so has he and this one is mine, and every single word of that was true.
Then I looked at Bucky, who was standing with his front feet on a chair at the end of that table, and who would have had the whole cake in eleven seconds given a clear run at it and would not have thought one thing about it either way, and I do not know why that was the thing but it was.
I pushed the plate across the table.
Sam said, are you sure, and I said yes, and he ate it, and it was fine, and everybody carried on and nothing happened at all.
The thing I want to say is that pushing the plate took about a second and the gate closing in my chest took about half a second, and the gate closed first, and I felt it close before I did anything about it, and nobody had told me that would happen.
The question, and the strange old words in it
John asks a question rather than giving an instruction, and the question is uncomfortable in a very specific way.
But whoso hath this world's good, and seeth his brother have need, and shutteth up his bowels of compassion from him, how dwelleth the love of God in him? (1 John 3:17)
Shutteth up. That is a physical word about a door. And the old phrase bowels of compassion is not delicate but it is accurate, because it names compassion as something felt in the middle of a person rather than decided in their head.
So the verse is describing exactly what happens in a chest. Something is open, and then something closes, and John treats the closing as the event worth asking about.
You are being asked about a door rather than about a decision, and 1 John 3:17 puts the whole question on shutting up. It is the Holy Spirit who makes that read as being understood instead of as being caught.
And it is a question and not a verdict. How dwelleth the love of God in him? John does not answer it. He leaves it standing, which is a much more searching thing to do than to condemn somebody.
You have not been given a verdict, and the sentence stops at a question mark. The written word leaves it open on purpose, and His Spirit is what makes an open question something a person can walk into rather than away from.
What he says to do about it
The next verse is the practical one and it is one of the shortest instructions John gives.
My little children, let us not love in word, neither in tongue; but in deed and in truth. (1 John 3:18)
My little children. That is the tone of the whole letter and it is the reason the previous question is not an attack. An old man is writing to people he is fond of and calling them children, and the question about a shut door sits inside that.
And the instruction is about deeds, which for a nine year old at a table means a plate moving four inches. Not a feeling about the plate. The plate.
You are able to do the deed even after the gate has closed, and 1 John 3:18 asks for the deed rather than the feeling. The Spirit of God is what makes that possible in the second after somebody notices what happened in their own chest.
And the verse after that gives the reason it matters, and it is about the person doing it: and shall assure our hearts before him. The deed settles something in the doer.
You have been given something that quiets your own heart rather than only helping somebody else's. 1 John 3:19 puts the assurance in the person acting, and the Holy Spirit is the one who moves that from a letter into a kitchen with paper hats in it.
So here is the true version, for anybody at their own party with one slice left.
You are not a worse person because a gate closed in you, and 1 John 3:17 asks about shutting up rather than about feeling. The Holy Spirit is what keeps that from being a rebuke and makes it the first honest description a child has ever been given of their own chest.
Everything in my argument was true. It was my birthday, it was my cake, and everybody had had two. If the whole thing had been decided on whether the argument was correct I would have eaten that slice and been entirely in the right.
You have been asked for the deed instead of the feeling, and that is a much smaller ask. 1 John 3:18 says in deed and in truth rather than in word and in tongue, and His Spirit is what makes a plate moving four inches count as the whole of it.
And this is for whoever is reading it out, who has their own eight seconds and has never described them to anybody. You were not being condemned in there. 1 John 3:17 ends in a question mark and John never answers it, and the Spirit of God is the one who makes an unanswered question feel like an open door.
Declare this over yourself
Say it out loud. You are in Christ and Christ is in you, so the authority to speak over what closed in your own chest is genuinely yours, delegated and never invented. God asks about shutting up rather than about feeling, and asks for the deed, so speak to the grip: you have standing to address it because He is the one who framed the question. An ambassador carries the King's word and never his own policy, so say what God has said and leave the outcome to Him. Every line below is 1 John 3:17 and 1 John 3:18 handed back in your own voice, and it is His Spirit, not your volume, that makes saying it a receiving.
- Grip I get on a thing that is genuinely mine, you are not the last word. The Word of God asks how the love of God dwelleth in a man who shutteth up his compassion, and it asks it as a question rather than passing a sentence.
- Argument I had ready in four seconds, you are finished in the name of Jesus. I am able to move the plate anyway, because 1 John 3:18 asks for deed and truth rather than for word and tongue.
- Father, You have never once judged me by the half second before I moved. I receive that today, and I thank You that Your word calls the people it questions little children in the very next sentence.
1 John 3:17
This message is free, and always will be. There is nothing to unlock, nothing to subscribe to, and nothing you owe for having received it.